[Version Information]
WALi-OpenNWA version: 0f994ef6a5cbe02200899575605ae35f227d9ddb (2017-07-12 11:45:09 -0500) "Added programs and files used for POPL18"
duet version: 0bb65ddfee3d65b76cb927b278e492b410b1c720 (2017-08-06 18:12:28 -0400) "Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/ark2' into Newton-ark2"
# Installed packages for 4.02.1+PIC:
apron              20160125  APRON numerical abstract domain library
base-bigarray          base  Bigarray library distributed with the OCaml compile
base-bytes             base  Bytes library distributed with the OCaml compiler
base-num               base  Num library distributed with the OCaml compiler
base-ocamlbuild        base  OCamlbuild binary and libraries distributed with th
base-threads           base  Threads library distributed with the OCaml compiler
base-unix              base  Unix library distributed with the OCaml compiler
batteries             2.5.3  a community-maintained standard library extension
camlidl                1.05  Stub code generator for OCaml
camlp4               4.02+7  Camlp4 is a system for writing extensible parsers f
cil                20150825  A front-end for the C programming language that fac
conf-gmp                  1  Virtual package relying on a GMP lib system install
conf-m4                   1  Virtual package relying on m4
conf-mathsat              1  Virtual package relying on a MathSAT system install
conf-mpfr                 1  Virtual package relying on library MPFR installatio
conf-perl                 1  Virtual package relying on perl
conf-python-2-7         1.0  Virtual package relying on Python-2.7 installation.
conf-which                1  Virtual package relying on which
cppo                  1.4.1  Equivalent of the C preprocessor for OCaml programs
deriving           20140904  Extension to OCaml for deriving functions from type
mathsat            20161206  MathSAT 5 SMT solver
menhir             20170101  LR(1) parser generator
mlgmpidl              1.2.4  OCaml interface to the GMP library
num                       0  The Num library for arbitrary-precision integer and
oasis                 0.4.8  Tooling for building OCaml libraries and applicatio
ocamlbuild                0  Build system distributed with the OCaml compiler si
ocamlfind             1.7.1  A library manager for OCaml
ocamlgraph            1.8.7  A generic graph library for OCaml
ocamlify              0.0.1  Include files in OCaml code
ocamlmod              0.0.8  Generate OCaml modules from source files
OCRS             20170627v3  Recurrence solver based on operational calculus
optcomp                 1.6  Optional compilation with cpp-like directives
ounit                 2.0.0  Unit testing framework loosely based on HUnit. It i
ppx_deriving            4.1  Type-driven code generation for OCaml >=4.02
ppx_tools        5.0+4.02.0  Tools for authors of ppx rewriters and other syntac
result                  1.2  Compatibility Result module
Z3                 20161217  Z3 SMT solver

Test Name Output Duet Output No. of Rounds Result Run Time (Prev.) Duet Result
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/c4b
gcd.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.364 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.367
kmp.c below duet 1 PASS
0.82 (0.716) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.848
qsort.c below duet 4 PASS
0.83 (0.663) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.945 (1.464)
speed_pldi09_fig1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.383 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
speed_pldi09_fig4_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.36 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.368
speed_pldi09_fig4_4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.465 (0.413) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.448
speed_pldi09_fig4_5.c below duet 1 PASS
0.357 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.382
speed_pldi10_ex1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.736 (0.652) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.762 (0.64)
speed_pldi10_ex3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.391 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.408
speed_pldi10_ex4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.378 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.375
speed_popl10_fig2_1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.386 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.409
speed_popl10_fig2_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.357 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.358
speed_popl10_nested_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.384 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.411
speed_popl10_nested_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.38 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.395
speed_popl10_sequential_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.345 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.346
speed_popl10_simple_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.405 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.393
speed_popl10_simple_single_2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.405 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.398
speed_popl10_simple_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.325 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.341
t07.c below duet 1 PASS
0.366 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.382
t08.c below duet 1 PASS
0.356 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.361
t09.c below duet 1 PASS
0.35 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.35
t10.c below duet 1 PASS
0.355 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.355
t11.c below duet 1 PASS
0.414 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.403
t13.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.378 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.395
t15.c below duet 1 PASS
0.353 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
t16.c below duet 1 PASS
0.366 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.364
t19.c below duet 1 PASS
0.344 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.351
t20.c below duet 1 PASS
0.345 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.351
t27.c below duet 1 PASS
0.398 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.39
t28.c below duet 1 PASS
0.386 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
t30.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.342 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.353
t37.c below duet 2 PASS
0.453 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.578
t39.c below duet 2 PASS
0.441 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.527
t46.c below duet 1 PASS
0.37 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.394
t47.c below duet 1 PASS
0.36 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
Total Below Time = 14.448 (was 13.804)
Above Time = 18.04 (was 15.167)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/misc-recursive
mult-rec.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.375 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.413
qsort_full.c below duet 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
12.046 (6.264) PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
30.513 (15.896)
rec1-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.35 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.376
rec1-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.35 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.369
rec1_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.342 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.351
rec1_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.334 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.343
rec2-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.335 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.38
rec2-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.342 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.361
rec2_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.327 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.336
rec2_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.325 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.363
rec-test.c below duet 2 PASS
0.341 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.353
sas03_bothbranches.c below duet 7 PASS
0.633 (0.52) PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.378 (0.673)
sas03.c below duet 2 PASS
0.649 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.831
simulated_lese_recursive.c below duet 2 PASS
0.378 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.417
Total Below Time = 17.127 (was 11.268)
Above Time = 36.784 (was 21.42)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/duet
count_up_down_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.313 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.318
count_up_down_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.319 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.311
divide.c below duet 1 PASS
0.317 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.317
factor_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.32 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.32
for_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.323 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.311
for_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.313 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.315
interproc.c below duet 1 PASS
0.317 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.32
mult.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.318 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.321
pointer_arith.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.302 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.303
quotient.c below duet 3 PASS
0.396 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.458 (0.41)
subtract.c below duet 1 PASS
0.315 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.331
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.329 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.342
sum01_bug02_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.39 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.401
sum01_real_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.322 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.334
sum01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.318
sum01_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.354 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.37
sum02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.344 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.34
sum03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.336 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.321
sum03_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.375 PASS
above 0 OKAY
0.376
sum04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.336 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.315
sum04_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.35 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.365
terminator_02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.316 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.324
terminator_02_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.338 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.338
terminator_03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.328
terminator_03_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.328 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.326
token_ring01_safe.c below duet 4 FAIL
148.866 (60.218) FAIL
above 4 TIMEOUT
300.022 (146.551)
token_ring01_unsafe.c below duet 4 OKAY
185.995 (81.964) PASS
above 4 TIMEOUT
300.043
toy_safe.c below duet EXCEPTION
177.065 TIMEOUT
above EXCEPTION
177.323 (149.576)
trex01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.751 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.367
trex01_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.354 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.379
trex02_safe2.c below duet 3 PASS
0.372 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.398
trex02_safe.c below duet 3 PASS
0.37 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.408
trex02_unsafe.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.368 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.41
trex03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.427 (0.385) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.43
trex03_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.402 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.409
trex04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.334 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.367
while_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.303 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.318
while_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.305 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.305
while_infinite_loop_3_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.319
Total Below Time = 524.564 (was 323.146)
Above Time = 789.921 (was 593.986)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests
above_litmus.c below duet 3 PASS
0.373 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.543 (0.406)
blogger_simplified1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.75 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.196 (1.007)
divided_difference2.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.006
mult-proc.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.356 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.386
mult-proc-params.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.391 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.428
popall.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.402 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.397
simulated_scc.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.452 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.463
Total Below Time = 302.729 (was 302.623)
Above Time = 303.419 (was 303.058)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/polynomial/assert
degree1_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.336 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.367
degree2_binomial.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.468 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.485
degree2_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.36 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
degree3_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.796 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.83
degree3_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.411 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.423
degree4_binomial.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.312 (1.14) PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.422 (1.196)
degree4_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.466 (0.422) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.514 (0.465)
degree5_binomial.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.404 PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.435
degree5_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.597 (0.525) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.616
Total Below Time = 6.15 (was 5.851)
Above Time = 6.475 (was 6.154)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/snlee/snlee_tests
cubic_with_square.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.35 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.368
cubic_with_square_interproc.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.415 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.438
cubic_with_square_nonlinear.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.343 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.362
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_interproc.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.406 (0.363) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.42
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.38 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.357
cubic_with_square_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.362 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.344
multi-input.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.43 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.411
multi-input_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.428 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.417
nondet_loop_bound.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.352 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.352
nondet_loop_bound_quartic.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.434 (0.358) PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.418
nondet_loop_bound_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.391 (0.346) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.376
nondet_loop_bound_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.339 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.339
nonlinear_stratified.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.35 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.381
nonlinear_stratified_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.355 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.368
quartic_with_cube.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.374 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.359
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.368 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.376
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.376 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.374
quartic_with_cube_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.388 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.38
quintic_with_quartic.c below duet 1 PASS
0.377 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.371
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.405 (0.365) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.404 (0.36)
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.445 (0.366) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.414
quintic_with_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.374 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.389
Total Below Time = 8.442 (was 8.069)
Above Time = 8.418 (was 8.172)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/FiniteDifferencing
degree2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.48 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.482
degree2_FD_AllAux_AllAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
2.33 (1.809) PASS
above 4 PASS
2.343 (1.844)
degree2_FD_AllAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
2.196 (1.716) PASS
above 4 PASS
2.327 (1.75)
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
0.649 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.646 (0.586)
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm_NonLinAsrt.c below duet 1 PASS
0.624 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.685 (0.614)
degree3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.532 (0.476) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.545 (0.49)
degree3_FD.c below duet 1 PASS
0.672 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.664 (0.603)
degree4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.412 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.407
Total Below Time = 7.895 (was 6.674)
Above Time = 8.099 (was 6.731)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LESE
loop.c below duet 1 PASS
0.373 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.388
loop_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.384 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.388
simulated_lese_parser.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.325
simulated_lese_sentinel.c below duet 1 PASS
0.328 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.345
Total Below Time = 1.404 (was 1.425)
Above Time = 1.446 (was 1.426)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LowerBound
lower_bound.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.329 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.338
Total Below Time = 0.329 (was 0.332)
Above Time = 0.338 (was 0.323)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LZ
lz77.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.003
Total Below Time = 300.004 (was 300.007)
Above Time = 300.003 (was 300.005)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-acceleration
array_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.338 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.344
array_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.358 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.353
array_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.335 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.345
array_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.339 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.336
array_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.361 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.358
array_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.346 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.332
array_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.333 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.335
const_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.333 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.32
const_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.329 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.313
diamond_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.339 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.328
diamond_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.345 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.339
diamond_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.356 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.347
functions_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.352 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.374
functions_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.355 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.366
multivar_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.319 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.313
multivar_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.312 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.323
nested_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.329 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.331
nested_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.33
overflow_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.309 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.304
phases_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.323 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.338
phases_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.349 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.341
phases_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.325 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.334
phases_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.329 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.339
simple_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.308 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.306
simple_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.313 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.309
simple_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.316 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.308
simple_false-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.3 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.316
simple_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.312 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.311
simple_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.304 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.303
simple_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.322
simple_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.31 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.318
underapprox_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.321 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.337
underapprox_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.322 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.316
underapprox_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.317 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.332
underapprox_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.316 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.324
Total Below Time = 11.503 (was 11.429)
Above Time = 11.545 (was 11.489)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-invgen
apache-escape-absolute_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.749 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.876
apache-get-tag_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
0.41 PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
0.417
down_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.32 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.33
fragtest_simple_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.368 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.388
half_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.346 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.351
heapsort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.687 (1.381) FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.673 (1.422)
id_build_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.324 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.347
id_trans_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 UNSOUND
UNSOUND
UNSOUND
OKAY
0.329 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 UNSOUND
UNSOUND
UNSOUND
OKAY
0.327
large_const_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.381 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.396
MADWiFi-encode_ie_ok_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.362 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.366
nested6_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.407 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.394
nested9_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.443 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.456
nest-if3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.384 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.403
NetBSD_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.322 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.336
sendmail-close-angle_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
0.353 PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
0.362
seq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.385 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.38
SpamAssassin-loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.982 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.967
string_concat-noarr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.356 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.358
up_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.334 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.337
Total Below Time = 9.242 (was 8.873)
Above Time = 9.464 (was 9.107)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-lit
afnp2014_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.322 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.313
bhmr2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.342 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.345
cggmp2005b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.376 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.389
cggmp2005_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.32 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.314
cggmp2005_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.315 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.342
css2003_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.463 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.46
ddlm2013_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.387 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.385
gcnr2008_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.666 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.698
gj2007b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
FAIL
0.356 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
FAIL
0.35
gj2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.354 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.349
gr2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.33
gsv2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.331
hhk2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.329 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.329
jm2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.332 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.342
jm2006_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.355 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.364
mcmillan2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.368 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.375
Total Below Time = 5.935 (was 5.864)
Above Time = 6.016 (was 5.956)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-new
count_by_1_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.318 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.312
count_by_1_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.326 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.324
count_by_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.316
count_by_k_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.325
count_by_nondet_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.325 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.33
gauss_sum_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.336 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.335
half_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.351 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.339
nested_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.387 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.374
Total Below Time = 2.693 (was 2.648)
Above Time = 2.655 (was 2.66)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loops
array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.406 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.397
array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.388 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.408
bubble_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 4 OKAY
OKAY
93.788 (71.256) PASS
PASS
above 4 OKAY
OKAY
141.484 (110.089)
bubble_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 2.084 (1.328)
above 4 2.095 (1.367)
compact_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.354 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.37
count_up_down_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.318 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.324
count_up_down_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.331 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.317
eureka_01_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
1.545 PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.595 (1.429)
eureka_01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.364 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.401
eureka_05_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.693 (0.535) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.717 (0.542)
for_bounded_loop1_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 UNSOUND
UNSOUND
OKAY
0.325 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 UNSOUND
UNSOUND
OKAY
0.33
for_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.327 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.327
for_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.323 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.303
heavy_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.451 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.43
heavy_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.441 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.454 (0.411)
insertion_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
1.297 (1.024) PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.3 (1.064)
insertion_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.643 (0.553) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.622 (0.56)
invert_string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.485 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.48
invert_string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.457 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.458
linear_sea.ch_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.378 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.387
linear_search_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.398 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.412
lu.cmp_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
30.534 (9.797) PASS
above 4 PASS
42.539 (14.003)
ludcmp_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 OKAY
29.777 (10.014) PASS
above 4 OKAY
42.672 (14.186)
matrix_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.631 (0.561) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.654 (0.582)
matrix_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.443 (0.396) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.445 (0.398)
n.c11_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.431 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.53 (0.457)
n.c24_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 OKAY
5.25 (2.65) PASS
above 4 OKAY
13.937 (9.185)
n.c40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.381 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.375
nec11_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.368 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.364
nec20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.356 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.362
nec40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.366 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.377
string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.553 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.568
string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.553 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.596
sum01_bug02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.381 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.398
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.336 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.337
sum01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.37 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.366
sum01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.336 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.332
sum03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.411 PASS
above 0 OKAY
0.417
sum03_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.332 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.355
sum04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.337 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.364
sum04_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.339
sum_array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.562 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.564
sum_array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.636 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.641
terminator_01_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.338 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.328
terminator_02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.377 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.459
terminator_02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.352 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.377
terminator_03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.334 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.325
terminator_03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.329 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.328
trex01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.45 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.579 (0.515)
trex01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.649 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.293 (1.167)
trex02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.392 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.417
trex02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.387 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.424
trex03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.631 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.987
trex03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.63 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.981
trex04_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.369 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.611
veris.c_NetBSD-libc__loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.339 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.343
veris.c_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 12.618 (4.607)
above 4 19.212 (7.25)
veris.c_sendmail__tTflag_arr_one_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.357 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.364
verisec_NetBSD-libc__loop_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.35 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.344
verisec_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 OKAY
7.755 (2.919) PASS
above 4 OKAY
12.982 (4.831)
vogal_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.672 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.665 (0.596)
vogal_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.64 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.672
while_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.324 (0.289) PASS
above 0 PASS
0.309
while_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.306 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.302
while_infinite_loop_3_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.316 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.314
while_infinite_loop_4_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.316 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.313
Total Below Time = 209.69 (was 128.966)
Above Time = 305.072 (was 189.408)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive
Ackermann01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
0.997 (0.77) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.028 (1.008)
Ackermann02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 OKAY
1.006 (0.759) PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.991 (0.958)
Ackermann03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
1.002 (0.783) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.046 (0.977)
Ackermann04_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
1.031 (0.746) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.053 (1.003)
Addition01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.483 (0.436) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.531 (0.459)
Addition02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.475 (0.42) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.527 (0.464)
Addition03_false-no-overflow.c below duet 2 PASS
0.487 (0.418) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.543 (0.456)
Addition03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.478 (0.428) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.547 (0.465)
BallRajamani-SPIN2000-Fig1_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.397 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.469 (0.4)
EvenOdd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.411 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.443
EvenOdd03_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.411 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.446
Fibonacci01_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.062 (0.635)
Fibonacci02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.008 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.992 (0.575)
Fibonacci03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.082 (0.633)
Fibonacci04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.511 (0.752)
Fibonacci05_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.008 PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.075 (0.618)
gcd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.45 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.523 (0.449)
gcd02_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
PASS
0.818 (0.653) FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
1.051 (0.776)
McCarthy91_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 OKAY
0.623 (0.524) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.771 (0.497)
McCarthy91_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
0.589 (0.519) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.727 (0.512)
MultCommutative_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.466 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.558
Primes_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 FAIL
1.133 (0.893) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
9.533
recHanoi01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 6 FAIL
12.399 (300.006) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.045 (1.083)
recHanoi02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.376 (0.336) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.397
recHanoi03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.369 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.408 (0.366)
Total Below Time = 1524.432 (was 1810.069)
Above Time = 34.359 (was 23.951)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive-simple
afterrec_2calls_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
OKAY
0.388 PASS
PASS
above 4 OKAY
OKAY
0.431
afterrec_2calls_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.371 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.397 (0.357)
afterrec_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.351 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.359
afterrec_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.338 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.361
fibo_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.934 (0.585)
fibo_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.92 (0.586)
fibo_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.913 (0.583)
fibo_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.932 (0.571)
fibo_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.008 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.91 (0.579)
fibo_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.962 (0.573)
fibo_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.927 (0.569)
fibo_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.916 (0.566)
fibo_2calls_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
186.97 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
68.967 (53.232)
fibo_2calls_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
182.796 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
71.402 (52.343)
fibo_2calls_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
185.108 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
72.158 (54.533)
fibo_2calls_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
192.007 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
72.269 (54.15)
fibo_2calls_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
185.735 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
72.001 (53.073)
fibo_2calls_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
186.845 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
71.352 (54.131)
fibo_2calls_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
185.442 (300.004) PASS
above 4 OKAY
70.995 (53.485)
fibo_2calls_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
184.815 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
73.007 (54.589)
fibo_2calls_2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
183.959 (300.004) PASS
above 4 OKAY
68.997 (52.239)
fibo_2calls_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
187.37 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 PASS
68.273 (51.992)
fibo_2calls_4_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
186.004 (300.004) PASS
above 4 OKAY
64.394 (51.963)
fibo_2calls_4_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
185.37 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
70.394 (52.245)
fibo_2calls_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
187.588 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
69.904 (51.129)
fibo_2calls_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
186.518 (300.005) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
72.747 (53.259)
fibo_2calls_6_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
182.331 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
71.845 (53.475)
fibo_2calls_6_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
184.564 (300.004) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
70.244 (52.989)
fibo_2calls_8_false-unreach-call.c below duet 8 OKAY
184.395 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
71.242 (54.118)
fibo_2calls_8_true-unreach-call.c below duet 8 FAIL
184.412 (300.004) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
68.314 (52.472)
fibo_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.931 (0.586)
fibo_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.894 (0.584)
fibo_7_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.941 (0.572)
fibo_7_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.005 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.921 (0.576)
id2_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.625 (0.518) FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.678 (0.61)
id2_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.627 (0.541) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.747 (0.612)
id2_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.589 (0.508) FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.687 (0.575)
id2_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.584 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.711 (0.609)
id2_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.394 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.422
id2_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.388 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.43
id_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.474 (0.415) FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.589 (0.516)
id_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.461 (0.418) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.586 (0.494)
id_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.483 (0.415) FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.616 (0.505)
id_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.485 (0.426) FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.59 (0.511)
id_i10_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.361 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.394
id_i10_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.369 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.397 (0.36)
id_i15_o15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.365 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.403
id_i15_o15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.348 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.39
id_i20_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.352 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.396
id_i20_o20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.363 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.386
id_i25_o25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.362 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.404
id_i25_o25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.361 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.389
id_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.365 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.389
id_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.358 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.389
id_o1000_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.369 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.392
id_o100_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.395 (0.35) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.389
id_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.366 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.395 (0.348)
id_o200_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.366 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.409
id_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.376 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.383
id_o3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.358 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.387
sum_10x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.361 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.405
sum_10x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.37 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.407
sum_15x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.382 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.432 (0.384)
sum_15x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.366 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.428 (0.375)
sum_20x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.379 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.403
sum_20x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.361 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.411
sum_25x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.37 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.402
sum_25x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.363 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.395
sum_2x3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.364 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.407
sum_2x3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.371 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.398
sum_non_eq_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.397 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.47 (0.393)
sum_non_eq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.407 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.435
sum_non_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.368 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.416 (0.37)
sum_non_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.364 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.409 (0.367)
Total Below Time = 6959.911 (was 9016.632)
Above Time = 1299.32 (was 980.156)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/rec-sv-benchmarks/rec-loop-lit
rec-afnp2014_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.373 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.376
rec-bhmr2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.388 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.431
rec-cggmp2005b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.605 (0.473) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.932
rec-cggmp2005_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.339 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.345
rec-cggmp2005_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.348 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.386
rec-css2003_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.579 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.631
rec-ddlm2013_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.444 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.519 (0.445)
rec-gcnr2008_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.661 (0.586) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.759 (0.652)
rec-gj2007b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
FAIL
0.37 FAIL
FAIL
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
0.402
rec-gj2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.384 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.407 (0.365)
rec-gr2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.372 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.408
rec-gsv2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.35 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.363
rec-hhk2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.342 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.367
rec-jm2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.361 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.383
rec-jm2006_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.385 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.419
rec-mcmillan2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.411 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.439
Total Below Time = 6.712 (was 6.313)
Above Time = 8.567 (was 8.083)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/rec-sv-benchmarks/rec-loop-new
rec-count_by_1_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.341 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.373
rec-count_by_1_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.356 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.366
rec-count_by_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.329 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.344
rec-count_by_k_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.356 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.367
rec-count_by_nondet_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.345 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.379
rec-gauss_sum_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.375 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.41
rec-half_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.376 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.418
rec-nested_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.516 (0.462) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.471
Total Below Time = 2.994 (was 2.851)
Above Time = 4.128 (was 3.884)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/recurrences
cubic_polynomial.c below duet 2 PASS
0.438 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.523 (0.448)
cubic_polynomial_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.442 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.538 (0.463)
edit_distance_bottom_up.c below duet 3 FAIL
79.78 (35.94) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
164.01 (84.587)
edit_distance_top_down.c below duet 3 FAIL
4.347 (2.612) FAIL
above TIMEOUT
300.093
log_log_n_solution.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.423 (0.375) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.491 (0.436)
log_log_n_solution_unsafe.c below duet 3 OKAY
0.414 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.475
log_n_solution.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.404 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.472 (0.409)
log_n_solution_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.417 (0.375) PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.485 (0.404)
multivariate_1.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.003
multivariate_1_unsafe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.007 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.004
multivariate_higher_order.c below duet 7 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
2.3 (1.482) FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
19.28 (5.867)
multivariate_higher_order_unsafe.c below duet 7 OKAY
OKAY
OKAY
2.323 (1.47) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 OKAY
OKAY
OKAY
19.662 (6.03)
n_cubed_solution.c below duet EXCEPTION
185.027 (91.303) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
84.848 (3.627)
n_cubed_solution_unsafe.c below duet EXCEPTION
0.026
above EXCEPTION
0.025
n_log_n_solution.c below duet 8 FAIL
0.954 TIMEOUT
above 4 FAIL
7.805 (300.004)
n_log_n_solution_unsafe.c below duet 8 OKAY
0.944 TIMEOUT
above 4 OKAY
3.01 (300.003)
n_squared_two_base_case_even.c below duet 2 PASS
0.375 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.428
n_squared_two_base_case_even_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.376 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.405
n_squared_two_base_case_odd.c below duet 2 PASS
0.373 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.412
n_squared_two_base_case_odd_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.372 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.42
pascals_dynamic.c below duet 3 FAIL
2.647 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
6.489 (4.552)
pascals_dynamic_unsafe.c below duet 3 OKAY
2.575 PASS
above 4 OKAY
6.555 (4.504)
pascals_iterative.c below duet 1 FAIL
2.234 (1.447) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.256 (1.442)
pascals_iterative_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
2.247 (1.433) PASS
above 4 OKAY
2.306 (1.472)
pascals_recursive.c below duet 8 FAIL
220.469 (300.009) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.886 (0.807)
pascals_recursive_unsafe.c below duet 8 OKAY
219.83 (300.009) PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.938 (0.842)
squared_solution.c below duet 9 FAIL
3.112 (1.921) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.178 (1.659)
squared_solution_unsafe.c below duet 9 OKAY
2.898 (1.958) PASS
above 4 OKAY
5.484 (1.557)
two_n_even.c below duet 2 PASS
0.36 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.404
two_n_even_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.365 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.407
two_n_odd.c below duet 2 PASS
0.372 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.405
two_n_odd_unsafe.c below duet 2 OKAY
0.372 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.434 (0.376)
two_to_n_over_two_even.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.01 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.241 (0.67)
two_to_n_over_two_even_unsafe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.004 PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.235 (0.666)
two_to_n_over_two_odd.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.011 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.256 (0.677)
two_to_n_over_two_odd_unsafe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.009 PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.21 (0.694)
two_to_n_squared.c below duet 5 FAIL
17.363 (8.047) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.453 (2.339)
two_to_n_squared_unsafe.c below duet 5 OKAY
18.073 (7.992) PASS
above 4 OKAY
3.528 (2.352)
two_to_two_to_n.c below duet 7 FAIL
0.802 (0.588) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.38 (0.641)
two_to_two_to_n_unsafe.c below duet 7 OKAY
0.77 (0.612) PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.37 (0.626)
Total Below Time = 2574.272 (was 2568.974)
Above Time = 1251.804 (was 1631.352)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/exponential
adding_and_mult.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.32 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.316
adding_and_mult_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.32 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.33
binary_search_array_tree.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
0.537 FAIL
FAIL
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
0.568
exp_add_linear.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.359 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.38
exp_add_linear_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.352 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.36
exp_add_loop_rec.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.341 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.35
exp_add_loop_rec_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.344 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.349
exp_add_loop_variable.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.358 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.354
exp_add_loop_variable_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.362 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.373
exp_with_linear_inner_loop.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.389 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.391
exp_with_linear_inner_loop_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.381 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.391
halving_log1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.386 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.405
linear_two_to_n.c below duet 6 FAIL
8.645 (300.006) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.305 (0.685)
linear_two_to_n_unsafe.c below duet 6 OKAY
7.588 (300.006) PASS
above 4 OKAY
1.354 (0.704)
loop_five_to_n.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.342 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.347
loop_five_to_n_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.349 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.356
non_loop_five_to_n.c below duet 6 TIMEOUT
300.004 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
4.842 (1.594)
non_loop_five_to_n_unsafe.c below duet 6 OKAY
121.997 (300.005) PASS
above 4 OKAY
4.781 (1.537)
power_log.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.374 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.397
power_log_modified.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.39 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.391
simple_exponential.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.346 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.35
simple_exponential_for.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.364 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.351
simple_exponential_for_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.367 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.349
simple_exponential_unsafe.c below duet 1 OKAY
0.347 PASS
above 4 OKAY
0.352
two_to_n_minus_n.c below duet 6 FAIL
7.806 (300.006) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.028 (0.78)
two_to_n_minus_n_loop.c below duet 6 FAIL
8.357 (300.006) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.049 (0.883)
two_to_n_minus_n_loop_unsafe.c below duet 6 OKAY
8.301 (300.006) PASS
above 4 OKAY
2.012 (0.947)
two_to_n_minus_n_unsafe.c below duet 6 OKAY
7.711 (300.007) PASS
above 4 OKAY
2.0 (0.751)
Total Below Time = 477.737 (was 2407.23)
Above Time = 27.831 (was 15.365)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/frankenstein/HOLA
01.c below duet 3 PASS
0.357 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.41
02.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.526 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.609
03.c below duet 1 PASS
0.367 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.392
04.c below duet 1 PASS
0.319 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.333
05.c below duet 3 PASS
0.51 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.632 (0.554)
06.c below duet 3 FAIL
6.364 (2.925) FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
8.457 (0.566)
07.c below duet 3 PASS
0.41 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.491 (0.437)
08.c below duet 3 PASS
0.844 (0.758) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
2.052 (1.643)
09.c below duet 3 PASS
0.481 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.714
10.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.615 (0.558) FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.827 (0.701)
11.c below duet 1 PASS
0.313 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.313
12.c below duet 3 PASS
0.611 (0.554) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.831 (0.742)
13.c below duet 3 PASS
0.417 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.482
14.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.386 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.418
15.c below duet 1 PASS
0.332 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.334
16.c below duet 1 PASS
0.342 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.36
17.c below duet 1 PASS
0.373 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.367
18.c below duet 1 PASS
0.347 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.356
19.c below duet 1 PASS
0.359 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.363
20.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
FAIL
0.463 PASS
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
FAIL
0.643 (0.538)
21.c below duet 3 PASS
0.423 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.499
22.c below duet 3 FAIL
PASS
0.468 FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
0.562
23.c below duet 1 PASS
0.333 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.326
24.c below duet 1 PASS
0.353 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.372
25.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.918 (0.797) FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.549 (1.253)
26.c below duet 3 FAIL
87.79 (300.005) TIMEOUT
above 4 FAIL
48.926 (0.634)
27.c below duet 1 PASS
0.356 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.379
28.c below duet 3 PASS
0.372 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.403
29.c below duet EXCEPTION
0.379
above EXCEPTION
0.394
30.c below duet 1 PASS
0.323 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.321
31.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.613 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.856 (0.769)
32.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.343 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.373
33.c below duet 3 PASS
0.774 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
1.308 (1.171)
34.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.345 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.356
35.c below duet 1 PASS
0.333 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.337
36.c below duet 3 PASS
1.957 (1.508) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
3.321 (2.542)
37.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.398 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.431
38.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.357 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.353
39.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.383 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.431
40.c below duet 3 PASS
0.488 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.683
41.c below duet 1 PASS
0.338 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.352
42.c below duet 3 PASS
0.593 (0.481) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.831 (0.654)
43.c below duet 3 PASS
0.432 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.559 (0.503)
44.c below duet 1 PASS
0.322 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.348
45.c below duet 3 FAIL
1.653 (1.35) FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
3.155 (2.399)
46.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.903 (0.799) FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.329 (1.104)
Total Below Time = 116.683 (was 323.838)
Above Time = 88.138 (was 28.101)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/frankenstein/relational
AGHKTW2017_bar.c below duet 1 PASS
0.335 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.364
AGHKTW2017_foo.c below duet 1 PASS
0.352 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.374
AGHKTW2017_loginSafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.535 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.598
AGHKTW2017_loopAndBranch_safe.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.379 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.387
BCK2011_gauss.c below duet 1 PASS
0.352 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.351
BCK2011_strength_reduction.c below duet 1 PASS
0.387 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.378
BCK2011_strength_reduction_linear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.361 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.377
fibonacci_information_flow.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.366 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.387
TA2005_fib2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.426 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.457
TA2005_fib.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.36 FAIL
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.354
Total Below Time = 3.853 (was 3.805)
Above Time = 4.027 (was 3.946)
/bat0/stac/Code/Ark2-Sandbox/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/canonical2017
canonical1_v_selfcomp.c below duet 1 0.434
above 4 0.462
canonical3_v_selfcomp.c below duet 1 0.555
above 4 0.656
canonical5_core.c below duet 3 FAIL
0.503 (0.442) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.583 (0.489)
canonical8_core.c below duet 1 0.587
above 4 0.657 (0.594)
Total Below Time = 2.079 (was 1.969)
Above Time = 2.358 (was 2.173)

>25% better
25%-10% better
No significant change
10%-25% worse
>25% worse