Most recent versions:
WALi-OpenNWA version: ab785b541835c12e4eca527e3baf02a4b70cc137 (2017-01-19 00:06:01 -0600)
duet version: bd12c0b14012e6243b5d44ff1a573ed5748ceaf2 (2017-01-18 09:19:12 +0100)
Test Name Output Duet Output No. of Rounds Result Run Time (Prev.) Duet Result
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/c4b
gcd.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.577 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.738
kmp.c below duet 1 PASS
1.38 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.013
qsort.c below duet 4 PASS
1.308 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.413
speed_pldi09_fig1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.504 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.589
speed_pldi09_fig4_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.829 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.079
speed_pldi09_fig4_4.c below duet 1 PASS
1.077 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.349
speed_pldi09_fig4_5.c below duet 1 PASS
1.078 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.527
speed_pldi10_ex1.c below duet 1 PASS
1.178 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.331
speed_pldi10_ex3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.683 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.8
speed_pldi10_ex4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.681 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.809
speed_popl10_fig2_1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.559 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.913
speed_popl10_fig2_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.567 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.875
speed_popl10_nested_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.708 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.044
speed_popl10_nested_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.61 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.707
speed_popl10_sequential_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.544 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.662
speed_popl10_simple_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.558 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.764
speed_popl10_simple_single_2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.668 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.887
speed_popl10_simple_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.438 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.52
t07.c below duet 1 PASS
0.626 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.87
t08.c below duet 1 PASS
0.543 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.756
t09.c below duet 1 PASS
0.489 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.565
t10.c below duet 1 PASS
0.487 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.634
t11.c below duet 1 PASS
0.561 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.925
t13.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.657 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.848
t15.c below duet 1 PASS
0.685 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.827
t16.c below duet 1 PASS
0.594 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.73
t19.c below duet 1 PASS
0.544 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.75
t20.c below duet 1 PASS
0.507 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.632
t27.c below duet 1 PASS
0.728 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.988
t28.c below duet 1 PASS
0.737 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.09
t30.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.572 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.744
t37.c below duet 2 PASS
0.973 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.888
t39.c below duet 2 PASS
0.951 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.444
t46.c below duet 1 PASS
0.528 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.962
t47.c below duet 1 PASS
0.478 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.638 (0.565)
Total Below Time = 24.607 (was 24.15)
Above Time = 37.311 (was 36.408)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/misc-recursive
mult-rec.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.619 (0.532) PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.711
qsort_full.c below duet 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
118.659
above TIMEOUT
300.021
rec1-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.522 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.625
rec1-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.482 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.611
rec1_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.472 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.555
rec1_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.465 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.522
rec2-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.487 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.6
rec2-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.476 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.579
rec2_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.469 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.551
rec2_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.464 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.524
rec-test.c below duet 2 PASS
0.443 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.514
sas03_bothbranches.c below duet 7 PASS
1.024 PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.821
sas03.c below duet 2 PASS
0.83 PASS
above 4 FAIL
8.06
simulated_lese_recursive.c below duet 2 PASS
0.539 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.683
Total Below Time = 125.951 (was 121.965)
Above Time = 316.377 (was 316.138)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/duet
count_up_down_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.416 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.437
count_up_down_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.425 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.428
divide.c below duet 1 PASS
0.415 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.412
factor_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.409 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.438
for_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.381 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.385
for_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.39 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.392
interproc.c below duet 1 PASS
0.367 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.407
mult.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.414 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.434
pointer_arith.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.393 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.405
quotient.c below duet 3 PASS
0.633 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.87
subtract.c below duet 1 PASS
0.398 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.424
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.597 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.716
sum01_bug02_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.529 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.62
sum01_real_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.448 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.461
sum01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.415 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.49
sum01_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.493 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.586
sum02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.61 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.678
sum03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.567 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.56
sum03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.457 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.463
sum04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.425 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.495
sum04_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.507 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.559
terminator_02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.478 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.58
terminator_02_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.482 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.535
terminator_03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.447 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.51
terminator_03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.55 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.594
token_ring01_safe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.209 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.026
token_ring01_unsafe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.039 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.026
toy_safe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.026 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.032
trex01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.576 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.816 (0.705)
trex01_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.66 (0.596) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.767
trex02_safe2.c below duet 3 PASS
0.538 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.708
trex02_safe.c below duet 3 PASS
0.532 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.702
trex02_unsafe.c below duet 3 PASS
0.543 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.719
trex03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.965 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.569
trex03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.978 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.673
trex04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.662 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.138
while_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.369 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.381
while_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.369 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.38
while_infinite_loop_3_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.402 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.398
Total Below Time = 918.514 (was 918.246)
Above Time = 922.214 (was 921.55)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests
above_litmus.c below duet 3 PASS
0.552 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.905
blogger_simplified1.c below duet 3 PASS
1.874 PASS
above 4 PASS
4.909
divided_difference2.c below duet 3 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
80.217 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
96.817 (120.93)
mult-proc.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.512 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.702
mult-proc-params.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.564 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.865
popall.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.586 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.626
simulated_scc.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.744 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.81
Total Below Time = 85.049 (was 79.517)
Above Time = 105.634 (was 129.524)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/polynomial/assert
degree1_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.493 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.854
degree2_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.411 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.923
degree2_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.572 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.98
degree3_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.393 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.965
degree3_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.822 FAIL
above 4 PASS
3.132
degree4_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.497 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.96
degree4_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
3.827 FAIL
above 4 PASS
4.343
degree5_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.127 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.82
degree5_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.952 FAIL
above 4 PASS
3.287
Total Below Time = 18.094 (was 17.823)
Above Time = 22.264 (was 22.026)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/snlee/snlee_tests
cubic_with_square.c below duet 1 PASS
0.472 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.51
cubic_with_square_interproc.c below duet 2 PASS
0.576 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.721
cubic_with_square_nonlinear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.49 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.505
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_interproc.c below duet 2 PASS
0.572 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.695
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.588 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.607
cubic_with_square_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.483 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.513
multi-input.c below duet 1 FAIL
6.418 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.526
multi-input_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
5.52 PASS
above 4 PASS
5.507
nondet_loop_bound.c below duet 1 PASS
0.556 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.616
nondet_loop_bound_quartic.c below duet 1 PASS
0.662 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.671
nondet_loop_bound_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.538 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.571
nondet_loop_bound_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.568 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.606
nonlinear_stratified.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.572 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.626
nonlinear_stratified_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.557 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.64
quartic_with_cube.c below duet 1 PASS
0.515 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.541
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.543 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.568
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.551 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.667
quartic_with_cube_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.517 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.534
quintic_with_quartic.c below duet 1 PASS
0.526 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.558
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear.c below duet 1 FAIL
5.759 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.666
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
5.46 PASS
above 4 PASS
5.607
quintic_with_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.592 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.558
Total Below Time = 33.035 (was 32.916)
Above Time = 28.013 (was 27.787)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/FiniteDifferencing
degree2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.808 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.877
degree2_FD_AllAux_AllAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
3.449 PASS
above 4 PASS
3.801
degree2_FD_AllAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
3.344 PASS
above 4 PASS
3.716
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
1.039 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.157
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm_NonLinAsrt.c below duet 1 PASS
1.067 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.227
degree3.c below duet 1 PASS
1.579 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.595
degree3_FD.c below duet 1 PASS
1.097 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.221
degree4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.783 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.887
Total Below Time = 13.166 (was 13.005)
Above Time = 14.481 (was 14.266)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LESE
loop.c below duet 1 PASS
0.584 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.65
loop_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.586 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.682
simulated_lese_parser.c below duet 1 PASS
0.434 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.477
simulated_lese_sentinel.c below duet 1 PASS
0.432 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.457
Total Below Time = 2.036 (was 2.011)
Above Time = 2.266 (was 2.276)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LowerBound
lower_bound.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.476 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.56
Total Below Time = 0.476 (was 0.479)
Above Time = 0.56 (was 0.531)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LZ
lz77.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.011
above TIMEOUT
300.009
Total Below Time = 300.011 (was 300.012)
Above Time = 300.009 (was 300.008)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-acceleration
array_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.459 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.459
array_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.463 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.498
array_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.465 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.499
array_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.446 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.452
array_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.442 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.506
array_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.438 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.47
array_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.424 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.449
const_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.415 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.432
const_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.42 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.411
diamond_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.456 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.515
diamond_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.476 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.495
diamond_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.547 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.569
functions_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.512 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.653
functions_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.502 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.665
multivar_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.414 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.44
multivar_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.408 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.422
nested_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.453 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.473
nested_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.444 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.46
overflow_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.397 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.395
phases_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.444 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.47
phases_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.476 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.524
phases_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.454 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.441
phases_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.441 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.466
simple_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.424 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.426
simple_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.405 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.423
simple_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.43 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.44
simple_false-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.406 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.423
simple_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.401 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.405
simple_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.394 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.403
simple_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.413 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.435
simple_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.398 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.418
underapprox_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.424 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.427
underapprox_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.433 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.432
underapprox_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.429 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.438
underapprox_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.415 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.426
Total Below Time = 15.368 (was 15.252)
Above Time = 16.26 (was 16.045)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-invgen
apache-escape-absolute_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
5.546 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
9.693
apache-get-tag_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.575 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
2.16
down_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.424 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.449
fragtest_simple_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.627 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.745
half_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.478 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.509
heapsort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
5.765 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
5.282
id_build_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.446 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.453
id_trans_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.498 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.541
large_const_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.578 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.622
MADWiFi-encode_ie_ok_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.539 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.681
nested6_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.676 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.695
nested9_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.974 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.395
nest-if3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.579 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.628
NetBSD_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.439 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.486
sendmail-close-angle_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.788 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.894
seq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.603 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.696
SpamAssassin-loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.857 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
2.04
string_concat-noarr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.546 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.602
up_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.463 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.462
Total Below Time = 23.401 (was 22.782)
Above Time = 29.033 (was 28.573)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-lit
afnp2014_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.42 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.464
bhmr2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.584 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.647
cggmp2005b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.595 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.631
cggmp2005_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.414 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.406
cggmp2005_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.425 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.433
css2003_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.619 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.721
ddlm2013_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.551 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.643
gcnr2008_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.47 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.311
gj2007b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
FAIL
0.832 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
FAIL
0.968
gj2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.437 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.439
gr2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.427 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.442
gsv2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.426 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.441
hhk2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.42 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.461
jm2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.538 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.764 (0.64)
jm2006_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.719 (0.57) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.893 (0.737)
mcmillan2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.741 (0.595) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.721 (0.641)
Total Below Time = 9.618 (was 9.19)
Above Time = 11.385 (was 10.76)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-new
count_by_1_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.501 (0.394) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.484 (0.399)
count_by_1_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.56 (0.461) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.508
count_by_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.4 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.533 (0.412)
count_by_k_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.484 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.596 (0.478)
count_by_nondet_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.451 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.508 (0.457)
gauss_sum_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.44 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.506 (0.43)
half_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.951 (0.794) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.127 (0.976)
nested_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.145 (0.883) PASS
above 4 PASS
1.193 (0.926)
Total Below Time = 4.932 (was 4.25)
Above Time = 5.455 (was 4.563)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loops
array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.615 (0.509) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.579
array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.575 (0.508) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.583
bubble_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 4 PASS
PASS
114.111 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
194.48
bubble_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 1.721
above 4 2.239
compact_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.515 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.606
count_up_down_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.434 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.424
count_up_down_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.413 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.442
eureka_01_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
6.046 PASS
above 4 PASS
7.894
eureka_01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
2.681 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.567
eureka_05_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.642 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.776
for_bounded_loop1_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.448 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.48
for_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.395 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.402
for_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.395 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.394
heavy_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.687 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.756
heavy_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.647 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.689
insertion_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.199 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.222
insertion_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.774 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.857
invert_string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.679 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.764
invert_string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.677 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.752
linear_sea.ch_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.628 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.783
linear_search_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.61 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.322
lu.cmp_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
14.756 PASS
above 4 PASS
28.854
ludcmp_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
15.653 PASS
above 4 PASS
29.845
matrix_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
1.146 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.234
matrix_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.641 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.634
n.c11_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.818 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.873
n.c24_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
9.919 PASS
above 4 PASS
64.6
n.c40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.555 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.708
nec11_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.995 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.086
nec20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.568 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.75
nec40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.564 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.713
string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
2.813 PASS
above 4 PASS
3.161
string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
2.38 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.602
sum01_bug02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.55 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.626
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.625 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.727
sum01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.514 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.606
sum01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.483 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.559
sum03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.52 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.542
sum03_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.696 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.739
sum04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.493 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.558
sum04_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.438 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.539 (0.472)
sum_array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.841 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.913
sum_array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.849 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.992
terminator_01_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.438 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.435
terminator_02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.646 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.023
terminator_02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.617 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.362
terminator_03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.543 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.6
terminator_03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.477 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.542
trex01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.841 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.611
trex01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
4.757 PASS
above 4 PASS
19.228
trex02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.551 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.82
trex02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.569 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.792
trex03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
2.033 PASS
above 4 PASS
9.409
trex03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
1.863 PASS
above 4 PASS
8.821
trex04_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.906 PASS
above 4 PASS
8.641
veris.c_NetBSD-libc__loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.426 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.53
veris.c_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 2.227
above 4 9.003
veris.c_sendmail__tTflag_arr_one_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.512 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.555
verisec_NetBSD-libc__loop_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.459 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.526
verisec_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
1.738 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
6.44
vogal_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.065 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.109
vogal_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.001 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.111
while_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.38 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.391
while_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.38 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.384
while_infinite_loop_3_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.397 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.409
while_infinite_loop_4_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.409 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.437
Total Below Time = 216.944 (was 206.655)
Above Time = 441.051 (was 435.863)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive
Ackermann01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
2.481 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.123
Ackermann02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
2.279 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.976
Ackermann03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
2.426 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.284
Ackermann04_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
2.389 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.887
Addition01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.853 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.174
Addition02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.842 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.148
Addition03_false-no-overflow.c below duet 2 PASS
0.873 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.226
Addition03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.866 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.242
BallRajamani-SPIN2000-Fig1_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.638 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.217
EvenOdd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
1.294 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.499
EvenOdd03_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
1.316 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.515
Fibonacci01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
11.618 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.758
Fibonacci02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 FAIL
14.244 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.625
Fibonacci03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 FAIL
17.432 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.799
Fibonacci04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
22.834 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.142
Fibonacci05_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
41.086 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.727
gcd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.836 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.192
gcd02_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
PASS
1.691 FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
3.053
McCarthy91_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
1.277 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.418
McCarthy91_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
1.225 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.402
MultCommutative_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
1.02 PASS
above 4 FAIL
2.251
Primes_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 FAIL
3.638 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
12.829
recHanoi01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 9 FAIL
7.847 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.708
recHanoi02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.586 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.749
recHanoi03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.593 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.74
Total Below Time = 142.184 (was 140.828)
Above Time = 59.684 (was 58.152)
/bat0/stac/Code/CSFE_JAVA_API/jbreck/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive-simple
afterrec_2calls_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.67 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.871
afterrec_2calls_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.596 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.781
afterrec_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.487 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.616
afterrec_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.486 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.576
fibo_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.954 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.482
fibo_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
17.091 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.572
fibo_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.628 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.498
fibo_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
13.199 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.595
fibo_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.686 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.518
fibo_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
12.807 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.542
fibo_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.605 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.558
fibo_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
14.018 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.516
fibo_2calls_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.022 PASS
above 4 PASS
69.207
fibo_2calls_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.015 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
67.237
fibo_2calls_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.023 PASS
above 4 PASS
68.262
fibo_2calls_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.034 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
67.051
fibo_2calls_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.027 PASS
above 4 PASS
69.314
fibo_2calls_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.045 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
68.548
fibo_2calls_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.027 PASS
above 4 PASS
66.944
fibo_2calls_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.022 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
66.475
fibo_2calls_2_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.055 PASS
above 4 PASS
68.429
fibo_2calls_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.026 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
64.535
fibo_2calls_4_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.012 PASS
above 4 PASS
70.055
fibo_2calls_4_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.012 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
68.083
fibo_2calls_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.01 PASS
above 4 PASS
69.743
fibo_2calls_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.029 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
65.824
fibo_2calls_6_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.021 PASS
above 4 PASS
70.81
fibo_2calls_6_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.259 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
72.018
fibo_2calls_8_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.023 PASS
above 4 PASS
70.578
fibo_2calls_8_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.027 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
69.879
fibo_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
17.385 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.512
fibo_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
12.561 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.519
fibo_7_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.434 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.507
fibo_7_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
11.519 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.567
id2_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.759 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.247
id2_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.885 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.273
id2_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.931 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.251
id2_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.741 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.265
id2_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.005 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.225
id2_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.963 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.171
id_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.909 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.312
id_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.926 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.285
id_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.898 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.305
id_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.902 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.308
id_i10_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.598 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.691
id_i10_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.555 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.692
id_i15_o15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.583 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.703
id_i15_o15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.584 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.701
id_i20_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.582 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.716
id_i20_o20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.578 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.697
id_i25_o25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.567 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.705
id_i25_o25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.561 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.709
id_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.592 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.709
id_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.591 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.694
id_o1000_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.575 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.718
id_o100_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.572 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.702
id_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.596 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.723
id_o200_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.595 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.725
id_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.587 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.697
id_o3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.566 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.704
sum_10x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.574 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.728
sum_10x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.536 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.734
sum_15x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.551 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.756
sum_15x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.545 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.719
sum_20x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.557 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.753
sum_20x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.549 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.732
sum_25x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.565 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.751
sum_25x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.548 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.732
sum_2x3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.541 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.758
sum_2x3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.558 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.721
sum_non_eq_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.662 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.857
sum_non_eq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.633 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.868
sum_non_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.541 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.779
sum_non_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.531 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.754
Total Below Time = 5569.907 (was 5568.013)
Above Time = 1292.792 (was 1284.718)

>25% better
25%-10% better
No significant change
10%-25% worse
>25% worse