Most recent versions:
WALi-OpenNWA version: c50415ec4c1bbe6ff06df2911e4b3deab9b59da9 (2016-12-14 13:13:36 -0600)
duet version: 64c4b056fb5428dd7d8a928e5a5d86c04525317a (2016-12-30 20:13:13 -0500)
Test Name Output Duet Output No. of Rounds Result Run Time (Prev.) Duet Result
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/c4b
gcd.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.581 (0.696) FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.687
kmp.c below duet 1 PASS
1.513 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.913
qsort.c below duet 4 PASS
1.349 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.435
speed_pldi09_fig1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.537 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.581
speed_pldi09_fig4_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.759 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.869
speed_pldi09_fig4_4.c below duet 1 PASS
1.297 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.402
speed_pldi09_fig4_5.c below duet 1 PASS
1.091 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.408
speed_pldi10_ex1.c below duet 1 PASS
1.18 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.274
speed_pldi10_ex3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.702 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.796
speed_pldi10_ex4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.72 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.825
speed_popl10_fig2_1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.572 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.812
speed_popl10_fig2_2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.582 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.758
speed_popl10_nested_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.702 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.95
speed_popl10_nested_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.649 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.696
speed_popl10_sequential_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.573 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.649
speed_popl10_simple_multiple.c below duet 1 PASS
0.596 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.692
speed_popl10_simple_single_2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.683 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.828
speed_popl10_simple_single.c below duet 1 PASS
0.47 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.528
t07.c below duet 1 PASS
0.667 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.821
t08.c below duet 1 PASS
0.57 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.685
t09.c below duet 1 PASS
0.515 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.576
t10.c below duet 1 PASS
0.509 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.597
t11.c below duet 1 PASS
0.577 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.81
t13.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.672 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.823
t15.c below duet 1 PASS
0.699 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.797
t16.c below duet 1 PASS
0.61 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.71
t19.c below duet 1 PASS
0.56 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.696
t20.c below duet 1 PASS
0.529 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.605
t27.c below duet 1 PASS
0.772 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.897
t28.c below duet 1 PASS
0.774 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.963
t30.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.547 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.68
t37.c below duet 2 PASS
0.974 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.869
t39.c below duet 2 PASS
0.939 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.362
t46.c below duet 1 PASS
0.551 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.914
t47.c below duet 1 PASS
0.53 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.566
Total Below Time = 25.551 (was 25.282)
Above Time = 35.474 (was 34.984)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/misc-recursive
mult-rec.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.576 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.725
qsort_full.c below duet 4 FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
82.08
above 4 TIMEOUT
300.021
qsort_full_TEST.c below duet 4 FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
93.194
above TIMEOUT
300.019
rec1-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.521 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.636
rec1-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.515 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.631
rec1_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.486 PASS
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.556
rec1_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.465 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.531
rec2-param_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.505 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.609
rec2-param_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.516 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.611
rec2_safe.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.482 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.547
rec2_unsafe.c below duet 2 PASS
0.462 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.53
rec-test.c below duet 2 PASS
0.467 FAIL
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.524
sas03_bothbranches.c below duet 7 PASS
1.0 PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.76
sas03.c below duet 2 PASS
0.781 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
1.045
simulated_lese_recursive.c below duet 2 PASS
0.541 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
0.684
Total Below Time = 182.591 (was 187.118)
Above Time = 609.429 (was 609.357)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/duet
count_up_down_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.439 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.453
count_up_down_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.429 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.461
divide.c below duet 1 PASS
0.447 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.441
factor_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.434 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.418
for_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.411 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.422
for_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.417 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.426
interproc.c below duet 1 PASS
0.389 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.405
mult.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.447 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.452
pointer_arith.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.396 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.402
quotient.c below duet 3 PASS
0.702 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.914
subtract.c below duet 1 PASS
0.436 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.433
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.644 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.707
sum01_bug02_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.541 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.597
sum01_real_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.449 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.464
sum01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.452 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.479
sum01_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.538 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.566
sum02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.739 (0.617) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.631
sum03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.6 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.598
sum03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.478 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.487
sum04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.45 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.488
sum04_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.528 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.581
terminator_02_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.478 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.553
terminator_02_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.496 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.529
terminator_03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.472 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.497
terminator_03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.533 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.563
token_ring01_safe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.066 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.023
token_ring01_unsafe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.068 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.016
toy_safe.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.058 TIMEOUT
above TIMEOUT
300.043
trex01_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.606 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.688
trex01_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.617 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.712
trex02_safe2.c below duet 3 PASS
0.565 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.711
trex02_safe.c below duet 3 PASS
0.557 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.7
trex02_unsafe.c below duet 3 PASS
0.566 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.71
trex03_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
1.005 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.327
trex03_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.996 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.29
trex04_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.637 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.012
while_infinite_loop_1_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.393 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.396
while_infinite_loop_2_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.377 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.4
while_infinite_loop_3_safe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.402 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.402
Total Below Time = 919.258 (was 919.106)
Above Time = 921.397 (was 921.288)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests
above_litmus.c below duet 3 PASS
0.58 PASS
above 4 FAIL
0.935
blogger_simplified1.c below duet 3 PASS
2.19 PASS
above 4 PASS
4.666
divided_difference2.c below duet 3 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
156.9 (128.84) PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
89.138
mult-proc.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.558 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.701
mult-proc-params.c below duet 3 PASS
PASS
0.608 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.817
popall.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.681 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.698
simulated_scc.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.883 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.915
Total Below Time = 162.4 (was 134.374)
Above Time = 97.87 (was 99.167)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/polynomial/assert
degree1_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.519 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.845
degree2_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.147 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.484
degree2_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
0.606 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.883
degree3_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.395 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.756
degree3_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.623 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.927
degree4_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
1.597 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.978
degree4_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.222 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.444
degree5_binomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.04 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.611
degree5_monomial.c below duet 1 PASS
2.535 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.772
Total Below Time = 13.684 (was 13.654)
Above Time = 16.7 (was 16.517)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/snlee/snlee_tests
cubic_with_square.c below duet 1 PASS
0.508 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.52
cubic_with_square_interproc.c below duet 2 PASS
0.595 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.704
cubic_with_square_nonlinear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.509 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.543
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_interproc.c below duet 2 PASS
0.587 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.683
cubic_with_square_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.535 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.543
cubic_with_square_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.515 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.531
multi-input.c below duet 1 FAIL
5.5 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.518
multi-input_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.797 PASS
above 4 PASS
5.528
nondet_loop_bound.c below duet 1 PASS
0.587 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.615
nondet_loop_bound_quartic.c below duet 1 PASS
0.649 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.669
nondet_loop_bound_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.63 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.579
nondet_loop_bound_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.545 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.536
nonlinear_stratified.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.6 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.63
nonlinear_stratified_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.569 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.652
quartic_with_cube.c below duet 1 PASS
0.565 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.569
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear.c below duet 1 PASS
0.529 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.54
quartic_with_cube_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.639 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.657
quartic_with_cube_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.541 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.548
quintic_with_quartic.c below duet 1 PASS
0.565 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.586
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear.c below duet 1 FAIL
5.51 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.513
quintic_with_quartic_nonlinear_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.748 PASS
above 4 PASS
6.08 (5.486)
quintic_with_quartic_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.642 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.586
Total Below Time = 22.865 (was 22.971)
Above Time = 33.33 (was 32.679)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/FiniteDifferencing
degree2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.872 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.896
degree2_FD_AllAux_AllAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
3.53 PASS
above 4 PASS
3.838
degree2_FD_AllAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
3.339 PASS
above 4 PASS
3.576
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm.c below duet 1 PASS
1.071 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.13
degree2_FD_FewAux_FewAssm_NonLinAsrt.c below duet 1 PASS
1.081 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.133
degree3.c below duet 1 PASS
1.368 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.409
degree3_FD.c below duet 1 PASS
1.127 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.162
degree4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.78 FAIL
above 4 PASS
0.795 (0.891)
Total Below Time = 13.168 (was 12.965)
Above Time = 13.939 (was 13.882)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LESE
loop.c below duet 1 PASS
0.624 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.681
loop_unsafe.c below duet 1 PASS
0.672 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.688
simulated_lese_parser.c below duet 1 PASS
0.464 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.491
simulated_lese_sentinel.c below duet 1 PASS
0.475 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.483
Total Below Time = 2.235 (was 2.177)
Above Time = 2.343 (was 2.372)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LowerBound
lower_bound.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.508 PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
0.526
Total Below Time = 0.508 (was 0.499)
Above Time = 0.526 (was 0.523)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/STAC/LZ
lz77.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.01
above TIMEOUT
300.006
Total Below Time = 300.01 (was 300.008)
Above Time = 300.006 (was 300.011)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-acceleration
array_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.472 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.464
array_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.488 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.5
array_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.482 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.516
array_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.477 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.482
array_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.502 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.519
array_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.456 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.477
array_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.456 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.464
const_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.473 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.465
const_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.454 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.457
diamond_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.503 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.53
diamond_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.507 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.514
diamond_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.553 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.564
functions_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.548 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.678
functions_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 3 PASS
0.523 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.769 (0.655)
multivar_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.495 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.462
multivar_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.437 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.454
nested_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.509 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.507
nested_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.496 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.5
overflow_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.408 (0.544) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.413
phases_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.464 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.483
phases_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.503 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.51
phases_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.451 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.464
phases_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.468 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.48
simple_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.442 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.451
simple_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.419 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.437
simple_false-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.453 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.446
simple_false-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.431 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.451
simple_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.422 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.432
simple_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.402 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.414
simple_true-unreach-call3.c below duet 1 PASS
0.444 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.445
simple_true-unreach-call4.c below duet 1 PASS
0.429 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.437
underapprox_false-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 PASS
0.448 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.46
underapprox_false-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.454 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.439
underapprox_true-unreach-call1.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.468 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.463
underapprox_true-unreach-call2.c below duet 1 PASS
0.455 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.447
Total Below Time = 16.392 (was 16.236)
Above Time = 16.994 (was 16.778)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-invgen
apache-escape-absolute_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
5.668 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
8.315
apache-get-tag_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.562 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.996
down_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.565 (0.47) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.505
fragtest_simple_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.678 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.761
half_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.533 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.549
heapsort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
3.581 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
FAIL
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
3.712
id_build_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.495 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.509
id_trans_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.506 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.532
large_const_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.646 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.664
MADWiFi-encode_ie_ok_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.608 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.665
nested6_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.74 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.754
nested9_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.068 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.316
nest-if3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.631 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.7 (0.636)
NetBSD_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
0.5 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.515
sendmail-close-angle_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.809 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
0.858
seq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.683 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.724
SpamAssassin-loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.745 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
PASS
1.815
string_concat-noarr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.599 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.638
up_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.5 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.504
Total Below Time = 22.117 (was 21.587)
Above Time = 26.032 (was 25.648)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-lit
afnp2014_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.454 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.611 (0.48)
bhmr2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.602 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.652
cggmp2005b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.62 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.663
cggmp2005_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.457 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.466
cggmp2005_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.45 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.468
css2003_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.662 (0.779) PASS
above 4 PASS
0.699
ddlm2013_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.582 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.613
gcnr2008_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.231 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.579
gj2007b_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
FAIL
0.749 PASS
FAIL
above 4 PASS
FAIL
0.824
gj2007_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.458 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.485
gr2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.461 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.479
gsv2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.448 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.46
hhk2008_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.462 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.462
jm2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.575 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.638
jm2006_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.645 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.717
mcmillan2006_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.627 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.656
Total Below Time = 9.483 (was 9.501)
Above Time = 10.472 (was 10.228)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loop-new
count_by_1_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.43 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.413
count_by_1_variant_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.508 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.514
count_by_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.432 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.428
count_by_k_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.489 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.494
count_by_nondet_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.44 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.465
gauss_sum_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.454 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.461
half_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.732 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.766
nested_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.835 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.882
Total Below Time = 4.32 (was 4.249)
Above Time = 4.423 (was 4.397)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/loops
array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.579 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.581
array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.577 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.592
bubble_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 4 PASS
PASS
100.992 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
188.395
bubble_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 1.846
above 4 2.397
compact_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.559 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.608
count_up_down_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.463 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.457
count_up_down_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.444 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.447
eureka_01_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
5.24 PASS
above 4 PASS
5.553
eureka_01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
2.871 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.511
eureka_05_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.282 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.399
for_bounded_loop1_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.48 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
FAIL
PASS
0.476
for_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.424 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.417
for_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.418 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.416
heavy_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.751 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.814
heavy_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.713 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.742
insertion_sort_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.11 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.192
insertion_sort_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.867 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.915
invert_string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.79 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.827
invert_string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.77 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.807
linear_sea.ch_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.642 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.787
linear_search_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.284 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.745
lu.cmp_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
14.379 PASS
above 4 PASS
27.635
ludcmp_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
14.628 PASS
above 4 PASS
27.917
matrix_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
1.251 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.242
matrix_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.668 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.752 (0.679)
n.c11_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
0.875 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.599
n.c24_false-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
10.734 PASS
above 4 PASS
56.675
n.c40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.56 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.651
nec11_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.939 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.955
nec20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.596 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.683
nec40_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.557 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.654
string_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
2.133 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.415
string_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.846 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.439
sum01_bug02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.544 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.602
sum01_bug02_sum01_bug02_base.case_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.651 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.706
sum01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.542 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.576
sum01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.492 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.527
sum03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.54 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.528
sum03_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.695 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.748
sum04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.52 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.562
sum04_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.462 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.482
sum_array_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.905 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.979
sum_array_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
0.974 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.021
terminator_01_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.464 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.457
terminator_02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.655 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.937
terminator_02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.609 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.193
terminator_03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.536 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.564
terminator_03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.486 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.509
trex01_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.842 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.177
trex01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
4.378 PASS
above 4 PASS
15.387
trex02_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.574 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.754
trex02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
0.56 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.761
trex03_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 3 PASS
2.112 PASS
above 4 PASS
7.68
trex03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 PASS
2.021 PASS
above 4 PASS
7.347
trex04_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.88 PASS
above 4 PASS
6.694
veris.c_NetBSD-libc__loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.462 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.551
veris.c_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 2.0
above 4 8.163
veris.c_sendmail__tTflag_arr_one_loop_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.536 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.587
verisec_NetBSD-libc__loop_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
0.48 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.533
verisec_OpenSER__cases1_stripFullBoth_arr_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 FAIL
1.656 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
5.53
vogal_false-unreach-call.c below duet 1 PASS
1.216 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.251
vogal_true-unreach-call.c below duet 1 FAIL
1.19 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.255
while_infinite_loop_1_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.401 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.395
while_infinite_loop_2_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.395 PASS
above 0 PASS
0.405
while_infinite_loop_3_true-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.418 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.396
while_infinite_loop_4_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 1 PASS
0.424 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.422
Total Below Time = 201.888 (was 196.979)
Above Time = 407.374 (was 404.699)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive
Ackermann01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
2.303 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
2.898
Ackermann02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
2.179 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.823
Ackermann03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
2.373 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
12.311
Ackermann04_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
2.328 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
3.128
Addition01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.869 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.089
Addition02_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.84 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.06
Addition03_false-no-overflow.c below duet 2 PASS
0.886 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.116
Addition03_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.866 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.129
BallRajamani-SPIN2000-Fig1_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.629 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.02
EvenOdd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
1.33 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.509
EvenOdd03_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
1.354 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.504
Fibonacci01_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
18.756 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.661
Fibonacci02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 FAIL
10.946 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.641
Fibonacci03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 FAIL
8.177 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.715
Fibonacci04_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
7.42 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.083
Fibonacci05_false-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
15.288 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.676
gcd01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 PASS
0.829 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.106
gcd02_true-unreach-call.c below duet 4 FAIL
PASS
7.03 FAIL
PASS
above 4 FAIL
PASS
2.491
McCarthy91_false-unreach-call_false-termination.c below duet 7 PASS
1.215 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.361
McCarthy91_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
1.167 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.394
MultCommutative_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
1.064 (0.909) PASS
above 4 FAIL
1.896
Primes_true-unreach-call.c below duet 3 FAIL
3.428 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
9.909
recHanoi01_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 9 FAIL
7.935 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
4.775
recHanoi02_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.62 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.769
recHanoi03_true-unreach-call_true-termination.c below duet 2 FAIL
0.622 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
0.756
Total Below Time = 100.454 (was 100.347)
Above Time = 62.82 (was 62.268)
/home/turetsky/Newton/WALi-OpenNWA/Examples/cprover/tests/sv-benchmarks/recursive-simple
afterrec_2calls_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.657 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.85
afterrec_2calls_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
PASS
0.636 PASS
PASS
above 4 PASS
PASS
0.8
afterrec_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.519 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.611
afterrec_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.503 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.615
fibo_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.554 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.427
fibo_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
8.117 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.4
fibo_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.821 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.403
fibo_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
7.737 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.427
fibo_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.541 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.392
fibo_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
7.74 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.414
fibo_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
42.661 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.398
fibo_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
7.716 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.398
fibo_2calls_10_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.011 PASS
above 4 PASS
62.2
fibo_2calls_10_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.008 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
62.654
fibo_2calls_15_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.024 PASS
above 4 PASS
61.777
fibo_2calls_15_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.013 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
61.298
fibo_2calls_20_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.012 PASS
above 4 PASS
61.406
fibo_2calls_20_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.029 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
62.266
fibo_2calls_25_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.008 PASS
above 4 PASS
58.961
fibo_2calls_25_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.032 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
62.622
fibo_2calls_2_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.029 PASS
above 4 PASS
60.036
fibo_2calls_2_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.017 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
62.22
fibo_2calls_4_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.018 PASS
above 4 PASS
63.448
fibo_2calls_4_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.032 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
63.227
fibo_2calls_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.014 PASS
above 4 PASS
61.159
fibo_2calls_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.025 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
61.635
fibo_2calls_6_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.037 PASS
above 4 PASS
60.118
fibo_2calls_6_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.033 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
62.941
fibo_2calls_8_false-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.052 PASS
above 4 PASS
61.908
fibo_2calls_8_true-unreach-call.c below duet TIMEOUT
300.024 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
61.491
fibo_5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
1.497 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.426
fibo_5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
21.129 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.451
fibo_7_false-unreach-call.c below duet 7 PASS
7.662 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.388
fibo_7_true-unreach-call.c below duet 7 FAIL
7.841 FAIL
above 4 FAIL
1.417
id2_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.76 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.168
id2_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.772 PASS
above 4 PASS
2.216
id2_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.788 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.218
id2_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.713 FAIL
above 4 PASS
2.169
id2_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.036 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.197
id2_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
1.016 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.189
id_b2_o3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.928 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.335
id_b3_o2_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.946 PASS
above 4 PASS
1.381
id_b3_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.948 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.323
id_b5_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.941 FAIL
above 4 PASS
1.313
id_i10_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.594 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.716
id_i10_o10_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.611 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.716
id_i15_o15_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.604 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.705
id_i15_o15_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.585 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.709
id_i20_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.591 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.71
id_i20_o20_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.593 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.711
id_i25_o25_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.609 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.7
id_i25_o25_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.612 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.708
id_i5_o5_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.591 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.719
id_i5_o5_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.589 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.711
id_o1000_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.602 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.726
id_o100_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.598 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.733
id_o10_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.618 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.711
id_o200_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.603 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.722
id_o20_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.605 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.737
id_o3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.604 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.715
sum_10x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.583 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.783
sum_10x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.58 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.763
sum_15x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.586 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.798
sum_15x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.576 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.775
sum_20x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.605 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.768
sum_20x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.585 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.766
sum_25x0_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.6 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.789
sum_25x0_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.572 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.774
sum_2x3_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.592 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.788
sum_2x3_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.577 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.829
sum_non_eq_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.7 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.858
sum_non_eq_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.671 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.835
sum_non_false-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.594 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.795
sum_non_true-unreach-call.c below duet 2 PASS
0.587 PASS
above 4 PASS
0.777
Total Below Time = 5568.614 (was 5567.84)
Above Time = 1170.24 (was 1170.018)

>25% better
25%-10% better
No significant change
10%-25% worse
>25% worse